
Is Anniyan a good movie? Sorry, no. It is mediocre. It could have been a good movie .. if Indian and Chandramukhi had never been made. However, they were; So the psycho Anniyan character keeps reminding the viewer of Indian thatha and because he also has multiple personality disorder, you almost expect him to sing ra ra sarasaku ra ra!!
Ok, the movie is not that bad. Vikram's Ambi is irritating at first, but his character slowly grows on you. He is hilarious in the TTR sequence in the train, and he is way too cute when he gives a love letter to Sada's parents. Vikram may end up getting flak for the Remo character - but I personally think he manages to pull it off too. Anniyan is the weakest link - his voice is weird, the eye darting is freaky and the hair-in-front effect makes you want to tear your hair out!
On the positive side, the theme of the movie is extremely thought provoking. Are we all not guilty of poor civic sense when in India? Hasnt public apathy become a way of life? Shankar needs to be applauded for talking about issues that people no longer think of as issues. However, after establishing a good solid story, and signing on one of the most talented actors, Shankar gets lazy, and copies Indian's screen play, mixes in concepts from the movie Seven and finally draws inspiration from Sidney Sheldon.
To top it all, there is a frame by frame remake of Matrix 3's big fight sequence (where neo fights hundreds of Mr.Smiths). This fight sequence has been picturized extremely well, showing us what Tamizh cinema is technically capable of - unfortunately, all of us have already watched the Matrix, and even from a story perspective, this sequence is absolutely contrived.
Of the supporting cast, Prakashraj is brilliant as always and Vivek reaches his peak! Sada? She carries on the tradition of totally mediocre Shankar movie heroines (remember not-so-pretty Ash in Jeans, overweight manisha in indian, jaded manisha in mudhalvan?....Genelia was an exception).
The songs are a big disappointment - they have been picturized poorly and are a big drag on the screenplay. Iyengar veetu has been totally wasted. It could have been imaginatively picturized, instead you have big gaudy indoor sets, lots of extras, and Vikram dressed in Raja costumes.
Ok, it is not entirely fair to say Anniyan copies Chandramukhi. Anniyan was probably launched even before CM. However, the two movies even use the same lighting techniques when the protagonist shifts from personality to another.
Shankar cheats when showing the alternating personality shifts between Anniyan and Remo. The shots have not been taken continuosly, Vikram's hair length and texture changes every 2 seconds. Vikram is a fabulous actor, Shankar need not have employed make up and lighting tricks to highlight the personality differences. Vikram could have just shown it through his acting.
There is another major gaffe. Sada does not recognize Remo's face; she does not even suspect once that he is Ambi. She does not realize his identity when he turns into Anniyan, but the second he talks about rules, she immediately knows its Ambi!! Also, Anniyan is smart enough to learn Java and HTML and makes his super hi tech website, but then he logs into his website from his home computer, making his ip address totally traceable. Is he not even smart enough to log in from a net cafe?
Sorry Shankar, I still dont get it. Where did you spend the 26 crores?